Coronavirus FAQ: How Do The Rules of 6 Feet And 15 Minutes Apply To The Delta Variant?
Each week, we answer frequently asked questions about life during the coronavirus crisis. If you have a question you'd like us to consider for a future post, email us at firstname.lastname@example.org with the subject line: "Weekly Coronavirus Questions." See an archive of our FAQs here.
Since the beginning of COVID, I have heard two numbers associated with reducing the risk of catching the virus from someone else. 6 feet – that's how far we were told to stay from others. And 15 minutes – that's said to be a cutoff for close contact. But the delta variant is more contagious. So shouldn't it be ... I dunno ... zero feet and 15 seconds? Seriously, what's the recommendation now?
First of all, the 6-feet, 15-minute Centers for Disease Control and Prevention definition was always an approximation, Dr. Leana Wen, an emergency physician and public health professor at George Washington University, points out.
"There was nothing magic about 6 feet and 15 minutes," she says. "However, we have to draw the line somewhere."
The distance was based on research dating back to the late 1800s about how far infectious droplets can travel through the air before falling to the ground. But it was never meant to be an ironclad guarantee — and as we know now, COVID-19 also spreads through aerosols that can travel more than 6 feet.
"In my view it was interpreted in too many places as a sort of rule that the virus would follow," says Harvard School of Public Health associate professor of epidemiology William Hanage. "Somewhat obviously, being in an unventilated space with a highly infectious person for an hour would not suddenly become 'safe' " if you sat more than 6 feet away from them.
"The risk might end up slightly lower," he adds, "but it wouldn't be zero."
The CDC used 6 feet for distance and 15 minutes for length of exposure as pre-conditions that would make it more likely that someone was exposed to enough virus to cause an infection, says Stanford University infectious disease fellow Abraar Karan.
"As with all pre-conditions, there are exceptions — namely, if you were exposed to more virus even over a shorter period of time (as we may expect from delta, which can cause viral load levels much higher than the previous dominant strain — or if you were exposed to less virus but over a longer period of time or in closer proximity)."
In fact, the CDC's website now explicitly points out that transmission can occur beyond 6 feet indoors via aerosolization, Karan says.
So how should you judge your risk?
There are a few specific things you can do to lower your risk, of course: get vaccinated, wear a mask, wash your hands, stay away from anyone who's sick. But in terms of time and distance, experts say to think more generally.
"I think it is important for people to think of this in terms of more likely and less likely rather than in terms of absolutes like 6 feet and 15 minutes," Karan says.
It's OK to rely on your own common sense, Wen points out. "I would just say to use common sense and a higher index of suspicion [now that Delta has taken over]."
For example, "emphasize that the closer you are to others, the more likely transmission can occur," Karan says, "and the further away, the less likely. The longer you are near someone, the more likely; and the shorter amount of time, the less likely. But also: Time spent matters, use of masks matters, being outdoors where droplets can't acclmulate matters and how infectious someone else is matters."
Consider the following factors, Hanage says: whether people are unvaccinated, whether people are indoors, poor ventilation, lack of mask use, duration of exposure, total number of infectious contacts, and total inoculum (number of infectious viral particles). (Ok — we'll give you a pass on not knowing how many viral particles you may or may not have been infected with. Just know with delta as the primary variant, it's likely much higher than it was previously.)
And how do you know when to test and quarantine?
Again, use your common sense, Wen urges. "If you were at a garden party with someone who ended up testing positive, but you don't recall that person and likely were not anywhere close to them, you probably don't need to test or quarantine. On the other hand, if you live with vulnerable family members and had a questionable exposure, maybe err on the side of caution and get tested."
In fact, she adds, "use a very high degree of suspicion" if you live with vulnerable people. For example, if you saw someone who later tested positive for only five minutes, that would warrant getting tested (but not until at least three days later, or you risk an inaccurate result.)
The bottom line: "Transmission is a complex process," Karan says. "No set number of feet or minutes can capture this fully."
Sheila Mulrooney Eldred is a freelance health journalist in Minneapolis. She's written about COVID-19 for many publications, including Medscape, Kaiser Health News, Science News for Students and The Washington Post. More at sheilaeldred.pressfolios.com. On Twitter: @milepostmedia.
Copyright 2021 NPR. To see more, visit https://www.npr.org.